Re: [Jack-Devel] AES67 / SMPTE ST 2110-30

Just received two of these (HP) I-210 "PCI 2.1" cards (from Amazon). 
Installed one of them in and old PC with a PCI-e 2.0 x 4 slot (thus only 
using part of the slot). Initially windows reported an error and it did 
not work. Went back to Ubuntu 17.10 on the same machine and it worked 
fine. (Same result as another person before me). Disabled the internal 
NIC and started Windows again. Voila, it worked ! Re-enabled the 
on-board NIC and it kept Working in windows. Just for reference.  Don't 
have a AVB audio device so cannot really test them. Looking if there is 
any AVB test software out there to use these two cards to transmit AVB 
based audio from one to the other.

 From talking to Focusrite regarding AES67 and the Rednet series and 
firmware support, got the following:  "With regards to AES67 
compatibility, this is possible for devices using the 'Brooklyn 2' Dante 
chipset. RedNet 3s ship with a 'Brooklyn 1' chipset, though it's 
possible to upgrade to a Brooklyn 2 (this would be chargeable). All of 
our devices using Brooklyn 2 modules have AES67 compliance following the 
latest firmware update available from RedNet Control"  (Focusrite 
Rednets use the Bonjour/mDNS protocol for discovery)

In conclusion, the 3 parts needed for full functionality on Linux
[1] Discovery - mDNS should be doable in Linux, right ?
[2] AoIP  / clocking - This AES67 project
[3] Control (of the device) - Windows/Mac for the moment. Hopefully 
suppliers will support some kind of new standard in the future for that 
as well ( HTML XML, JSON  or other open messaging over IP to configure 
the unit). The Rednet3 will keep the routing/configuration after power 
cycling thus until then that should be done under Windows.

Looking forward on the progress  of this project !


On 10/1/2017 4:32 PM, Christoph Kuhr wrote:
> A few years back there had been a AES67/Ravenna implementation. But 
> the developer and ALX Networks could not agree on the license. The 
> developer wanted to publish it under GPL, which ALX Networks did not 
> want. So the implementation was dumped. Well, that is the story how I 
> know it.
> The developer was Florian Faber, but he is no member of the jack-devel 
> or linux-devel list anymore. Perhapes, he might have some useful 
> insights, if you manage to find a contact. ;-)
>
> On 09/30/2017 06:12 AM, happy musicmaker wrote:
>> There are some different I210 card versions it seems, any 
>> recommendations ? 
>
> They are all ok. I have different versions myself: Intel I210, HP 
> I210TI. But make shure it is no I217, because they have no traffic 
> shaping queues. Although they suport HW PTP timestamping.
>
>
>
> BR,
> CK
>
>
>>
>>
>> On Thu, Sep 28, 2017 at 6:11 PM, Christoph Kuhr 
>> <[hidden] <mailto:[hidden]>> wrote:
>>
>>     With an Intel I210 NIC you can already have AVB in combination with
>>     Jack. But you have to do some coding yourself to fit your purposes..
>>
>>
>>     BTW:
>>     I would never recommend buying MOTU.
>>
>>
>>     BR,
>>     Ck
>>
>>
>>     On 09/28/2017 08:33 AM, happy musicmaker wrote:
>>
>>         MOTU just released the 828es with AVB and USB standard compliant
>>         and two ADAT I/O and Web based (not ALSA) mixer. That would be,
>>         for now, the ultimate (AVB)  interface for Linux,  if it works.
>>
>>         On Thu, Sep 28, 2017 at 11:31 AM, happy musicmaker
>>         <[hidden] <mailto:[hidden]>
>>         <mailto:[hidden]
>>         <mailto:[hidden]>>> wrote:
>>
>>              That is such good news.  What(low cost)  hardware would 
>> this
>>              development be used on to support the developers with
>>              testing/debugging and maybe even development ?
>>
>>              * MOTU LP32 (Preferred)
>>              * MiniDSP
>>         https://www.minidsp.com/products/network-audio/avb-dg
>> <https://www.minidsp.com/products/network-audio/avb-dg>
>> <https://www.minidsp.com/products/network-audio/avb-dg
>> <https://www.minidsp.com/products/network-audio/avb-dg>> (I think
>>              MOTU's switch uses midDSP switch hardware)
>>
>>              I hope someday it will be possible to connect 4 or more 8
>>         channel
>>              ADAT modules (32 channels) to a PC under Ubuntu via AVB
>>         with low
>>              latency. The only option to get this done under Windows 
>> is a
>>              Focursrite DANTE based Rednet 3 right now because
>>         Thunderbolt is not
>>              really available there as well. Plan to get Rednet3,  but
>>         that does
>>              not solve the Linux environment which I prefer. Would love
>>         to be
>>              able to use the Rednet 3 under Linux but since DANTE is
>>         proprietary
>>              , so unlikely.
>>
>>              My two wishes:
>>                 [a] Multi (16+) channel low latency audio I/O using ADAT
>>         audio AD/DA
>>                 [b[ Bitwig  supporting LV2 plugins.
>>
>>              With those two,  the Linux Audio environment would be
>>         perfect and
>>              the world a better place.
>>
>>              *(Apology for the re-sends and ignore the previous edits.
>>         Web based
>>              Gmail is such a annoyance and un-logically structured)*
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>         
>>         Jack-Devel mailing list
>>         [hidden]
>>         <mailto:[hidden]>
>> http://lists.jackaudio.org/listinfo.cgi/jack-devel-jackaudio.org
>> <http://lists.jackaudio.org/listinfo.cgi/jack-devel-jackaudio.org>
>>
>>
>>     
>>     Jack-Devel mailing list
>>     [hidden] 
>> <mailto:[hidden]>
>> http://lists.jackaudio.org/listinfo.cgi/jack-devel-jackaudio.org
>> <http://lists.jackaudio.org/listinfo.cgi/jack-devel-jackaudio.org>
>>
>>
>

1513752392.26483_0.ltw:2, <4cebb659-852a-167b-95ba-aeb55b2d556b at gmail dot com>